Utah Film Center has moved! Sign up for our newsletter for exciting updates.
You're looking for a helpful report related to Mahler's Symphony No. 4, specifically the 2003 recording by the San Francisco Symphony, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas, in lossless format. Here's some information:
Symphony Details
Gustav Mahler's Symphony No. 4 in G major is a large-scale work, consisting of four movements:
Recording Details
The 2003 recording by the San Francisco Symphony, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas, is a highly acclaimed performance. Here's what you can expect:
Sound Quality and Performance
The recording is known for its excellent sound quality, with a clear and detailed representation of the orchestra. Michael Tilson Thomas's interpretation of Mahler's Symphony No. 4 is characterized by:
Critical Reception
The recording received widespread critical acclaim upon its release. Reviewers praised Thomas's nuanced interpretation, the orchestra's excellent playing, and the recording's technical quality.
Technical Specifications (example)
If you're looking for specific technical details, here's an example of what you might find:
Keep in mind that actual technical specifications may vary depending on the specific release and encoding.
Where to Find the Recording
You can try searching for the recording on various online music platforms, such as:
Make sure to verify the recording's authenticity and sound quality before making a purchase.
Captured live at Davies Symphony Hall in September 2003, Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT)
and the San Francisco Symphony (SFS) deliver a definitive, audiophile-grade performance of Mahler’s Symphony No. 4. This recording is a cornerstone of their multi-Grammy-winning Mahler cycle, lauded for its transparency, warmth, and meticulous attention to detail. Performance & Interpretation
Often called Mahler’s most "tuneful" work, the Fourth Symphony explores themes of childhood innocence and celestial beauty through a 19th-century lens.
The Adagio (Third Movement): MTT’s interpretation of the expansive slow movement is widely regarded as one of the finest ever recorded. It is notably slow—taking roughly 25 minutes—yet remains "never static," building to a "musical lightning" climax that critics from Classics Today describe as breath-taking.
Vocal Finale: Soprano Laura Claycomb provides the vocal finale with a sense of "fresh innocence," perfectly capturing the "boyish simplicity" Mahler intended for this folk-tune-inspired movement.
Orchestral Brilliance: The SFS woodwinds, particularly the oboes and clarinets, are praised for their "lusty" and "exquisite" playing throughout. Technical Details & Formats
Originally released by SFS Media, this recording was a pioneer in high-resolution audio for American orchestras. Review of Gustav Mahler / Michael Tilson Thomas Cycle
The 2003 recording of Mahler: Symphony No. 4 featuring Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) and the San Francisco Symphony is a benchmark release in their acclaimed Mahler cycle. This live recording from Davies Symphony Hall is highly regarded for its "old world" phrasing, particularly in the strings, and its exceptional audio quality. Album Overview Artist: San Francisco Symphony Conductor: Michael Tilson Thomas Soloist: Laura Claycomb (Soprano) Label: SFS Media (Catalogue No: SFS0004 or 821936-0004-2) Recording Date: Live, September 24–28, 2003
Awards: The series won multiple Grammys, including Classical Album of the Year and Best Orchestral Performance for this cycle. Lossless & High-Resolution Formats
This recording was designed for audiophiles and is available in several high-quality formats:
Hybrid SACD: Playable on standard CD players and Super Audio CD players.
Lossless Downloads: Available in Hi-Res FLAC, ALAC, and WAV (typically 96 kHz / 24-bit) via audiophile platforms like Presto Music and HighResAudio.
Vinyl: Part of the Mahler Project Vinyl Box-Set on 180-gram vinyl. Movement Breakdown The performance runs approximately 62 minutes:
Bedächtig. Nicht eilen: Lyrical and "upbeat," evoking childhood innocence.
In gemächlicher Bewegung. Ohne Hast: Features a solo violin (Alexander Barantschik) tuned up a step to sound like a medieval fiddle.
Ruhevoll (Poco Adagio): Highly praised for its "Old Europe" string portamenti and profound emotional depth.
Sehr behaglich: The "Heavenly Life" finale featuring soprano Laura Claycomb. Critical Reception
Gramophone Magazine: Recommended the recording, noting the orchestra was in "top form". You're looking for a helpful report related to
MusicWeb International: Described it as a "moving and distinctive experience".
Classics Today: Hailed it as "one of the truly great recordings ever lavished on the Fourth". If you'd like, I can help you find: The best current pricing for the SACD or Hi-Res download.
More details on the other symphonies in the MTT/SFS Mahler cycle. Technical specs for the specific 24-bit/96kHz master. Mahler Project Complete CD Box Set - Michael Tilson Thomas
In 2003, the San Francisco Symphony (SFS) and Music Director Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) released a landmark recording of Gustav Mahler’s Symphony No. 4 in G major. This performance, captured live at Davies Symphony Hall between September 24–28, 2003, remains a standout entry in their Grammy-winning Mahler cycle for its lush sonics and luminous interpretation. A Luminous Interpretation
The Fourth is often regarded as Mahler’s most "tuneful" and upbeat symphony, drawing on the composer's nostalgic memories of youth. Tilson Thomas’s reading is characterized by a "warm and affectionate" tone that balances lucidity with a distinctive "old world" phrasing.
The Slow Movement (Ruhevoll): This expansively paced Adagio is a highlight of the recording, noted for its "achingly beautiful" high string notes and a climactic "bolt of musical lightning".
The Vocal Finale: Soprano Laura Claycomb delivers the vocal solo "Das Himmlische Leben" ("The Heavenly Life") with a "pure and affecting" tone, capturing the required "boyish simplicity" of a child's vision of heaven. High-Fidelity Lossless Sound
The 2003 recording was originally released as a Hybrid SACD (Super Audio CD) on the orchestra’s own label, SFS Media.
Engineering: Produced by Andreas Neubronner and engineered by Markus Heiland, the recording is praised for its "big, wide dynamic range" and "excellent instrument placement".
Formats: For audiophiles seeking the "new" lossless experience, the performance is available in various high-resolution formats beyond the physical SACD. It can be found on Apple Music in Lossless and Spatial Audio (Dolby Atmos), as well as on high-res sites like HRAudio.net. Critical Reception
Critics have largely hailed this account as one of the finest in the MTT/SFS cycle. While some reviewers noted Tilson Thomas’s tendency toward slower-than-average tempi in the third movement, most agree that the "exemplary" playing of the San Francisco Symphony and the detailed recording quality make it a "disc not to be missed". Mahler: Symphony No. 4 by Michael Tilson Thomas
A Radiant Vision: Mahler’s Symphony No. 4 with Michael Tilson Thomas and the San Francisco Symphony
In the vast and often imposing landscape of Gustav Mahler’s symphonic output, the Fourth Symphony occupies a unique and cherished position. It is the shortest of his symphonies, scored for the smallest orchestra, and perhaps the most deceptive in its simplicity. In 2003, the San Francisco Symphony, under the baton of Music Director Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT), captured this work in a recording that stands as a benchmark of the digital age. Released as part of their ongoing Mahler cycle, this particular iteration—sought after by audiophiles in lossless formats—remains a testament to the synergy between conductor, orchestra, and the elusive spirit of Mahler’s music.
The Concept: Through a Child’s Eyes
Mahler’s Fourth Symphony is often described as the "Wunderhorn" symphony, owing its thematic material to the composer’s settings of German folk poems. The overarching theme is a child’s view of heaven—a paradise of earthly delights free from the weight of adult suffering. However, to play it merely as "childish" is to miss the profound irony and undercurrent of darkness that Mahler weaves into the score.
Michael Tilson Thomas has long been celebrated as a master interpreter of Mahler, known for his ability to balance the grandiose architecture of the music with moments of startling intimacy. In this 2003 recording, MTT approaches the work with a distinct clarity of vision. He understands that the "simplicity" of the Fourth is a mask; the performance is refined, luminous, and meticulously detailed, avoiding the bombast that can sometimes plague interpretations of Mahler’s larger works.
Movements of Light and Shadow
The first movement, marked Bedächtig, nicht eilen (Deliberately, not rushed), opens with the famous sleigh bells. In this recording, the San Francisco Symphony’s playing is crisp and translucent. The engineering captures the chamber-music quality of the writing, allowing the woodwinds to sing out with character and warmth. MTT’s tempos are fluid, capturing the pastoral quality of the music while maintaining a propulsive energy that keeps the listener engaged.
The second movement, a scherzo titled Freund Hein spielt auf (Friend Death strikes up), introduces a macabre dance. The concertmaster is called upon to retune their violin to sound harsher and more eerie, representing the dance of death. The San Francisco Symphony’s strings handle this transition with aplomb, creating a texture that is unsettling yet undeniably virtuosic. MTT navigates the shifting moods—from the ghostly to the grotesque—with a deft hand, ensuring the irony lands without overwhelming the music’s lyricism.
The third movement, a sprawling Adagio, is the emotional heart of the symphony. It is a movement of profound stillness and expanding variations. Here, the string section of the SFS produces a sound of sumptuous beauty. MTT paces the movement with patience, allowing the long, singing lines to breathe. The climax, a sudden blaze of light in the major key, is handled with stunning impact, the brass ringing out with a golden resonance that showcases the orchestra's technical prowess.
The Heavenly Finale
The defining element of the Fourth Symphony is its finale, which features a soprano soloist singing "Das himmlische Leben" (The Heavenly Life). The choice of soprano for this recording was critical, and the performance features the radiant voice of Laura Claycomb.
Claycomb’s interpretation is a highlight of the disc. Her voice is bright and agile, perfectly suited to the childlike, yet spiritual nature of the text. She navigates the wide intervals and the awkward shifts in tessitura with apparent ease. More importantly, she captures the duality of the text—the joy of the saints dancing and the delightful, if slightly gruesome, imagery of the slaughtered lamb. It is a performance of great charm, devoid of the operatic heaviness that can sometimes weigh this movement down.
Audiophile Considerations: The Lossless Advantage
The mention of this recording in "lossless" formats—typically FLAC or ALAC—is significant. Mahler’s orchestration, while smaller here than in other symphonies, is incredibly detailed. The subtle use of percussion, the blend of woodwinds, and the dynamic range of the strings require high-resolution audio to be fully appreciated.
The 2003 production values are exemplary. The recording balances the need for a warm, concert-hall ambiance with the clarity of modern digital engineering. In a lossless format, the listener can hear the "bite" of the brass, the specific timbre of the sleigh bells, and the placement of the soloist within the orchestral texture. It is a listening experience that bridges the gap between the analytical and the emotional, allowing the audiophile to hear "into" the performance.
Conclusion
The 2003 recording of Mahler’s Symphony No. 4 by the San Francisco Symphony and Michael Tilson Thomas remains a vital document of one of the great conductor-orchestra partnerships of the modern era. It is a reading that embraces the work’s contradictions: it is sunny yet shadowed, simple yet sophisticated. For those seeking a definitive digital recording of this masterpiece, one that benefits immensely from high-fidelity listening, this release remains a touchstone of the Mahler discography. It captures not just the notes on the page, but the very essence of Mahler’s heavenly vision.
2003 recording of Gustav Mahler’s Symphony No. 4 by the San Francisco Symphony (SFS), conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas
(MTT), is a critically acclaimed entry in their complete Mahler cycle. San Francisco Symphony Key Album Details Recording Date: Captured live from September 24–28, 2003 , at Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco. Release Date: Originally released in March 2004 Featured Soloist: Laura Claycomb performs the vocal finale, Das himmlische Leben ("The Heavenly Life"). Format & Quality: The recording was made using Direct Stream Digital (DSD) technology and was initially released as a Hybrid Super Audio CD (SACD) . It is available in various lossless formats , including 24-bit high-resolution downloads (e.g., FLAC/ALAC) on platforms like HighResAudio Presto Music Performance Highlights Critical Reception:
Reviewers have praised the performance for its "lucid and luminous" interpretation and "clear, colorful, and sensitive" orchestral playing. Distinctive Timing: MTT’s reading of the third-movement
is notably expansive, lasting over 25 minutes, making it one of the slowest recorded versions of this movement. Audio Engineering: Recording Details The 2003 recording by the San
The production is noted for its rich tonality and wide dynamic range, specifically engineered for the michaeltilsonthomas.com other symphonies from the MTT/SFS Mahler cycle or compare this recording to other famous versions of the Fourth?
San Francisco Symphony Mahler Recording Project on SFS Media
The San Francisco Symphony (SFS) recording of Mahler’s Symphony No. 4, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT)
and recorded live in September 2003, is a cornerstone of their Grammy-winning Mahler cycle. Recording & Format Details
Recording Date: Captured live at Davies Symphony Hall from September 24–28, 2003.
Original Format: Released as a Hybrid SACD (SFS Media, Catalogue No: SFS0009), which includes both a high-resolution Super Audio CD layer and a standard CD layer. Lossless Availability:
Physical: The original Hybrid SACD remains the definitive physical lossless source.
Digital: High-resolution lossless downloads (24-bit/96kHz) in FLAC, ALAC, and WAV formats are available through Presto Music and HighResAudio.
Streaming: Accessible in lossless quality via Apple Music Classical and Qobuz. Performance Highlights Mahler Symphony 4 Tilson-Thomas 821936-0004-2 [TD]
Mahler: Symphony No. 4 recording featuring the San Francisco Symphony and conductor Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) was recorded live at Davies Symphony Hall between September 24–28, 2003
. This performance is widely celebrated as one of the highlights of their award-winning Mahler cycle for its "warm and affectionate" interpretation and "lucid and luminous" sound quality. San Francisco Symphony Recording Details & Lossless Quality This 2003 recording was released on the orchestra's own SFS Media label : Originally released as a Hybrid SACD Lossless Availability : High-fidelity, lossless versions are available through: 24-bit high-resolution downloads Apple Music Classical in lossless audio. 180-gram vinyl as part of the Mahler Project vinyl box set. Audio Fidelity : Reviewers from HRAudio.net
note the recording's "big, wide dynamic range" and excellent instrument placement. HRAudio.net Key Performance Highlights
The performance is noted for its "upbeat and tuneful" character. michaeltilsonthomas.com Laura Claycomb
performs the finale, "Das himmlische Leben" (The Heavenly Life), with a delivery described as pure and freshly innocent. Interpretation : MTT's reading of the third movement (
) is particularly praised for its "daringly slow pace" that remains "gorgeously sustained". Orchestral Detail
: Critics highlight the "exquisitely played" woodwinds and the "clear, colorful" playing of the San Francisco Symphony. HRAudio.net I. Bedächtig. Nicht eilen. Recht gemächlich (Deliberate. Unhurried. Quite leisurely) II. In gemächlicher Bewegung. Ohne Hast (In leisurely motion. Without haste) III. Ruhevoll (Poco adagio) (Peaceful) IV. Sehr behaglich (Very comfortably) michaeltilsonthomas.com purchasing options for the SACD or vinyl, or would you like a comparison with other recordings in MTT’s Mahler cycle? Mahler: Symphony No. 4 - Recordings - Michael Tilson Thomas
This 2003 recording of Gustav Mahler’s Symphony No. 4 by the San Francisco Symphony (SFS) under the baton of Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) is widely regarded as a pinnacle of their Grammy-winning Mahler cycle. Captured live at Davies Symphony Hall in September 2003, it features soprano Laura Claycomb in the celestial finale. 💿 Recording Profile
Format: Originally released on Hybrid SACD by the orchestra's own label, SFS Media.
Audio Quality: Recorded in DSD (Direct Stream Digital), providing a massive dynamic range and deep soundstage that audiophiles prize for its "lossless" clarity.
Performance Context: Edited from a series of live performances (Sept 24-28, 2003), though critics note the audience is virtually inaudible, maintaining a studio-like polish. 🎼 Key Interpretive Highlights
Critics and listeners often highlight specific choices MTT makes in this rendition:
The Adagio (Third Movement): Features a "daringly slow" pace in the first variation, anchored by the SFS cello section. Reviewers from MusicWeb International noted a distinct "old Europe" feel with expressive string portamenti (sliding between notes).
Childlike Innocence: Soprano Laura Claycomb is praised for her "feisty" and "moving" delivery of the fourth movement, which depicts a child’s view of heaven.
Orchestral Detail: The woodwind playing—particularly the clarinets and oboes—is cited for its character and technical perfection. 💎 Collector's Notes
Availability: You can find this recording on platforms like Presto Music or as part of the massive MTT Mahler Project box set.
Legacy: This specific recording helped the SFS/MTT partnership earn a reputation as the "most exciting Mahler combination" of the early 2000s. If you're interested in the lossless aspect,
A comparison of this 2003 version against MTT's other Mahler recordings?
Details on the full 17-SACD box set if you're looking to collect the whole series?
Mahler Symphony No. 4 recording featuring the San Francisco Symphony (SFS) and conductor Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) was recorded live at Davies Symphony Hall
from September 24–28, 2003. This "new" release from that era is a cornerstone of the orchestra's Grammy-winning Mahler cycle on their in-house label, Performance Overview : Features soprano Laura Claycomb
, who is praised for her "boyish simplicity," "pure" tone, and "affecting" delivery in the finale. Interpretive Style : MTT’s approach is described as lucid, luminous, and affectionate , walking a line between "innocence and sophistication". Orchestral Highlights
: The SFS woodwinds and first-chair players receive special praise for their "cheeky" and "colorful" solos, particularly in the scherzo and first movement. The Adagio MTT keeps the tempo moving
: Notable for a "daringly slow pace" in the first variation that reviewers found "gorgeously sustained" and "transcendent". Classics Today Lossless & Audio Quality
This recording is celebrated for its high-fidelity production, originally captured in Direct Stream Digital (DSD) michaeltilsonthomas.com : Originally released as a Hybrid SACD
(Super Audio CD), which includes a lossless CD stereo layer playable on standard players and a high-resolution multichannel layer for SACD systems. Lossless Availability
: It is currently available in lossless digital formats like FLAC, ALAC, and WAV (16-bit/44.1 kHz or higher) through retailers such as Presto Music Sonic Profile
: The recording is noted for "ideal clarity," "natural perspective," and a "wide dynamic range" that allows every detail, from suspended cymbals to harp tones, to register clearly. Presto Music Awards & Recognition The recording won Best Orchestral Performance Classical Album of the Year at the 49th Annual Grammy Awards It is considered one of the highlights of the MTT-SFS Mahler Project
, which has sold over 130,000 units and earned seven Grammys in total. Presto Music Mahler: Symphony No. 4/San Francisco/Thomas
The San Francisco Symphony (SFS) and Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) delivered a definitive account of Mahler: Symphony No. 4, originally recorded live at Davies Symphony Hall in September 2003. Released as part of their acclaimed, multi-Grammy-winning Mahler cycle, this recording is frequently cited for its warmth, lucidity, and demonstration-class audio quality. Performance Highlights
A Radiant Interpretation: Tilson Thomas approaches the Fourth—Mahler’s most tuneful and "upbeat" symphony—with a mix of luminous clarity and underlying shadow. Critics have praised the "silkiness" of the third-movement Adagio, calling it a high point of the entire SFS cycle.
Exceptional Soloist: American soprano Laura Claycomb provides the vocal finale ("Das himmlische Leben"). Her performance is lauded for its "boyish simplicity" and charm, perfectly capturing the child's vision of heaven that Mahler intended.
Orchestral Detail: The recording highlights the San Francisco Symphony’s exceptional wind and string sections, with every coloristic detail—from sleigh bells to harp flecks—rendered with natural perspective. Audio & Format Details
This recording was a milestone for SFS Media, the first in-house label established by a major American orchestra.
Gustav Mahler: Symphony No. 4 in G major
Performed by: San Francisco Symphony Conductor: Michael Tilson Thomas Recording Date: 2003 Format: Lossless
Introduction
Gustav Mahler's Symphony No. 4 in G major is one of the most popular and recognizable works in the classical music repertoire. The symphony is a cornerstone of Mahler's oeuvre, showcasing his mastery of orchestration, harmony, and thematic development. This paper will provide an overview of the symphony, its historical context, and a critical analysis of the 2003 performance by the San Francisco Symphony, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas.
Historical Context
Mahler composed his Symphony No. 4 between 1899 and 1901, a period of significant personal and professional change. He had recently taken up the position of director of the Vienna State Opera and was grappling with the challenges of his new role. The symphony is often seen as a reflection of Mahler's fascination with the Wunderhorn collection of German folk songs, which he had previously drawn upon in his Des Knaben Wunderhorn song cycle.
The Symphony
The symphony consists of four movements:
Performance Analysis: San Francisco Symphony, Michael Tilson Thomas (2003)
The 2003 performance of Mahler's Symphony No. 4 by the San Francisco Symphony, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas, is notable for its clarity and precision. The orchestra delivers a nuanced and detailed reading of the score, with a strong emphasis on Mahler's characteristic rhythmic complexities.
The performance features:
Lossless Recording
The lossless recording format ensures that the performance is captured with exceptional fidelity, preserving the nuances of the orchestra's playing and the acoustic characteristics of the concert hall. The recording quality is characterized by:
Conclusion
The San Francisco Symphony's 2003 performance of Mahler's Symphony No. 4, conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas, is a compelling and authoritative interpretation of this beloved work. The lossless recording format ensures that the performance is preserved with exceptional fidelity, making it a valuable addition to any classical music collection. This paper has provided a critical analysis of the symphony, its historical context, and the performance, highlighting the excellence of the San Francisco Symphony and Michael Tilson Thomas's conducting.
This is an excellent pick for anyone seeking a historically informed, warmly human, and sonically pristine interpretation of Mahler’s Fourth. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the 2003 San Francisco Symphony / Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) lossless recording.
Enter soprano Laura Claycomb. Mahler demands a childlike voice, not a Wagnerian soprano. Claycomb sings "Das himmlische Leben" (The Heavenly Life) with a pure, floated tone. Crucially, MTT keeps the orchestration transparent. You hear the clarinets mimicking the animals, the bassoon mimicking the cook, and the celesta mimicking the angels. In the final line—"Sankt Peter im Himmel sieht zu" (St. Peter in Heaven looks on)—Claycomb’s pianissimo floats into the hall’s silence. In a lossless file, the silence between the last note and the applause is black, empty, and perfect.
Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) and the San Francisco Symphony share one of the most celebrated conductor-orchestra partnerships of the late 20th and early 21st centuries. Their complete Mahler cycle on the SFS Media label is widely regarded as a landmark achievement—balancing scholarly rigor with the white-hot passion of a live performance tradition.
This 2003 recording of Symphony No. 4 in G major represents an ideal entry point to that cycle. Unlike the sprawling cosmic dramas of Mahler’s later symphonies, No. 4 is intimate, neoclassical in structure, and seen through a child’s vision of heaven. Composed primarily in 1899-1900, it is the most optimistic and classically scaled of his symphonies, yet it still carries Mahler’s signature irony—a heavenly joy that never quite forgets earthly sorrow.
For decades, the discography of Gustav Mahler’s symphonies has been a battlefield of titans. From Bruno Walter’s pioneering warmth to Leonard Bernstein’s neurotic ecstasy, from Claudio Abbado’s luminous transparency to Sir Georg Solti’s thunderous power, every generation of conductors has tried to unlock the secret cosmology of Mahler’s sound. Yet, in the pantheon of digital recordings, one name stands as a bridge between the 20th and 21st centuries: Michael Tilson Thomas (MTT) and his legendary partnership with the San Francisco Symphony.
Specifically, their 2003 recording of Mahler’s Symphony No. 4 has achieved near-mythic status among audiophiles and scholars. Initially released as a hybrid SACD on the SFS Media label, this performance has recently seen a resurgence in demand—not just for its musical interpretation, but for its technical perfection. Collectors are now searching specifically for "Mahler Symphony No 4 San Francisco Symphony Michael Tilson Thomas 2003 lossless new" —a phrase that signifies the holy grail of digital listening.
But why this recording? Why this year? And why is the lossless format essential to experiencing what MTT and the SFO achieved? This article unpacks the magic of that 2003 session, the interpretive genius of Tilson Thomas, and why you need to hear it in pristine, uncompressed audio.
MTT refuses to dawdle. Where others wallow in rustic nostalgia, MTT keeps the tempo moving, revealing that the "child’s view of nature" is actually quite neurotic. The woodwinds of the San Francisco Symphony—Robert Ward (principal oboe) and Timothy Day (flute)—play with a wit that is almost ribald. The climax of the development section is ferocious, a sudden blast of Mahlerian terror that feels genuinely shocking.